Questions raised on keeping Mohammad Siraj out, is the team management's 'choice' weighing heavily?

Samira Vishwas

Tezzbuzz|22-11-2026

Delhi: The issue of Mohammed Siraj's name not being in India's playing eleven for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington is being discussed across the country on different platforms. Will talk only about cricket here. Whatever may be the outcome of this test, the pace attack of Jasprit Bumrah, Akashdeep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj selected by the team management for this test, from cricket point of view, even the experts have not been able to digest it and from Sunil Gavaskar to Kapil Dev, no one has supported the thinking of head coach Gautam Gambhir on this selection or should we say, the management of the entire team.

The decision to keep Siraj out is still under question

India's brilliant comeback in Wellington Test, Jaiswal-Rahul hit half-centuries

Although the issue of not selecting Ravindra Jadeja and Nitish Kumar Reddy along with Siraj is hot, but on the Basin Reserve pitch, where the ball was getting good movement in the beginning, the team management, despite playing with four pacers, left out Siraj, who is India's highest wicket-taker in the current round of the World Test Championship and England, with a record of 144 wickets in 48 Tests at an average of 29.63.

His courage and fitness to play all 5 Tests in the last series was not hidden from anyone.

Despite his brilliant performance in England, Siraj did not get a chance

Against England, Siraj took 23 wickets in the last Test series in England and he was out of the team while Prasidh and Kamboj, who together took 15 wickets, came into the team.

In the same series, Jadeja had a record of 516 runs and 7 wickets and he was out of the team while Washington was selected with a performance of 284 runs and 7 wickets. It is true that on the basis of the performance shown in England, the team cannot be selected for the Test in New Zealand after several months, but how can we ignore the fact that even those selected do not prove to be better than Siraj on his current form.

Questions raised on team management strategy on the very first day of Wellington Test

On top of that, New Zealand's recovery from 70-5 on the first day in the Wellington Test and reaching 243-5 proved the team management's thinking wrong.

The team was missing Siraj's consistently accurate bowling and talent to break partnerships. Still, it is not that the team management had no reason to keep Siraj out of the team: after that England tour, they are attributing Siraj's record of total 21 wickets in 7 Tests and 5 wickets in the last 7 innings as a decline in his performance.

Siraj's performance declined or did the team management lose confidence?

Former India bowling coach Paras Mhambrey also cited lack of communication and lack of a proper policy for the use of Siraj during the two-month break as the biggest concerns.

The team management is spoiling a good bowler on the plea of ​​its 'preference'. His gradual exit from the team is not hidden from anyone, first in white ball cricket and now in Test also.

Mhambrey believes that Siraj has 48 Test match experience and his role in sharing the workload with Bumrah cannot be ignored after seeing him bowl a few innings for no apparent reason. R Ashwin calls this a 'common' thing in the current coach's era and such examples are increasing.

Silence on Siraj's selection, Kotak replied in press conference

How serious the team management is on this issue was known only when it was known in the press conference after the first day's play in the Test that questions would be raised on the bowling chosen, so the team manager sent batting coach Sitanshu Kotak to give 'answer'. He says, the playing eleven selected is not just for the initial session, but has been selected keeping in mind the entire 5-day test. According to him, the issue of Siraj not playing does not need any more discussion than this.

IPL 2027: Mahela Jayawardene gets big responsibility in Delhi Capitals

Constant neglect affects player's morale.

The history of cricket is full of such examples when the personal preference or unnecessary 'logic' of the team management overpowers the right thinking, then such decisions cause the biggest loss to the player and the team. The player's morale breaks and the pressure of being 'not needed in the team' becomes even more dominant after the return. Then the only thought that works most in the player is that if he does not perform as per the thinking of the team management, then he will be out of the team. Only those who do not face the threat of being dropped from the team play well.

FAQ

Why was Mohammed Siraj left out of the playing eleven of the Wellington Test?

The team management selected Jasprit Bumrah, Akashdeep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj as fast bowlers.

How many test wickets has Mohammed Siraj taken?

Siraj has taken 144 wickets in 48 Test matches at an average of 29.63.

How many wickets did Siraj take in the last Test series against England?

Mohammad Siraj had taken 23 wickets in the last Test series against England.