Mohammed Siraj snub under scanner as India pacers struggle! Kotak defends team selection after New Zealand fightback in 1st Test
NEW DELHI: India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand, insisting that the selectors and team management had picked the best possible combination despite the pacer's omission coming under scrutiny after a difficult opening day for India's bowling attack at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday.
With Jasprit Bumrah doing most of the damage, India's other pace options struggled to make an impact as New Zealand recovered from 70/5 to reach 243/5 at stumps. Henry Nicholls remained unbeaten on 113, while Glenn Phillips was six runs short of a century at 94 not out, the pair putting together an unbroken 173-run stand for the sixth wicket.
Siraj's absence was particularly noticeable as Anshul Kamboj, playing in his place, managed just one wicket for 57 runs in 18 overs. Prasidh Krishna went wicketless, conceding 58 runs in 16 overs, while Akash Deep returned figures of 1/33. Bumrah, meanwhile, finished with 3/52 from 17 overs.
Kotak explains why Siraj was left out
Asked about Siraj's omission at the post-day press conference, Kotak backed the selection call and said the team management had considered the conditions and opposition while settling on its best XI.
"I think at a time they pick the team, they think about the best XI, and that’s what played. Nothing wrong with Siraj, they thought of the best possible XI and played. Sri Lanka was different conditions. Not wrong decision to drop Siraj," Kotak said.
He also explained the thinking behind India's bowling combination, pointing to the different skills offered by the pace attack and the decision to include Washington Sundar because New Zealand had four left-handers in their XI.
"On current attack: Two bowlers swing the ball well and two seam the ball well. And have pace. When you pick XI, you think about all days. Picked Washi because of four left-handers in opposition XI," he added.
The decision, however, came under the spotlight as Bumrah repeatedly troubled the New Zealand batters while the other Indian bowlers struggled to maintain pressure after the new ball lost its shine.
'Prasidh is an attacking bowler'
Kotak also defended Prasidh, whose expensive spell included several boundary-scoring deliveries, saying the Karnataka pacer was an attacking option who could be expensive while searching for wickets.
"Prasidh is an attacking bowler and he can go for runs. People like it when he picks wickets, and they don’t when they go for runs," Kotak said.
India had made an impressive start after winning the toss, with Bumrah removing Tom Latham, Devon Conway and Daryl Mitchell before dismissing Tom Blundell to reduce the hosts to 70/5. Kamboj also struck early, but Nicholls and Phillips turned the contest around with a patient yet increasingly assured partnership.
Kotak felt India had an opportunity to make further inroads, particularly with a chance to dismiss Nicholls going down.
"The pitch helped with the new ball, the weather was good and sunny so it dried out. We should have taken that catch, Rishabh Pant went for the catch but it was close to Devdutt Padikkal," he said.
Nicholls eventually reached his 12th Test century, while Phillips continued to counter-attack as India's bowling attack lost its early bite. Bumrah was the only bowler who consistently threatened, leaving India with plenty to ponder after surrendering control of a day that had begun so promisingly.